Checked, then printedEach story lists its facts, their sources and how they were verified.
NewsKhata
न्यूज़खाता

Every story shows its sources.

← Front page

World

Trump, Xi and Putin meet together for the first time, issue a four-point peace declaration

The US, Chinese and Russian leaders talked for about 90 minutes in Shenzhen and promised to work on nuclear risks, UN reform and steady energy supplies, but the details are thin.

The Shenzhen skyline seen across wetlands
File photo: The Shenzhen skyline seen from Hong Kong. Photo: Sparktour / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

For the first time ever, the leaders of the United States, China and Russia sat down together at one table. Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin held their first trilateral meeting on Thursday in Shenzhen, in southern China, on the sidelines of the APEC summit, and came out with a short four-point "Declaration Towards Peace", according to PTI.

The talks ran for about 90 minutes, PTI and Russia's TASS news agency reported. IANS said the leaders met at the Kylin Villa in the city, during the 33rd APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting, which China is hosting this year.

So what did they actually agree on? Going by the text reported by PTI and TASS, the declaration does four things. First, the three, all permanent members of the UN Security Council, say they want to reform the United Nations so it can deal with global problems better. Second, they plan to raise production and supply of refined petroleum products, meaning fuels like petrol and diesel, and stressed that energy flows need to stay steady.

Third, they said the consent of countries and the legal protection given to state officials come first, and that the International Criminal Court and similar bodies should not overstep their jurisdiction, PTI reported. The ICC is the court in The Hague that tries people accused of war crimes. Fourth, and perhaps the line that will get the most attention, they repeated that "a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought", and agreed to talk about cutting nuclear risks and stopping the spread of nuclear weapons.

Before the three-way meeting, Trump met Xi and Putin one-on-one, IANS reported. He told reporters the US and China both want energy to keep moving through the Strait of Hormuz, the narrow sea lane next to Iran through which Gulf oil is shipped out. On the war in Ukraine, Trump sounded hopeful that the US and China could both help, IANS reported, though he did not say how.

Trump also argued that the three countries, as the biggest nuclear powers, were in a good position to cut back their weapons and lower the chance of them ever being used, IANS reported. IANS added that his talks with Xi were their first in two months, after the two met in Washington in September.

Why should this matter to someone in Pune or Patna? Big-power deals tend to ripple outward. Anyone in India keeping an eye on fuel prices will want to watch the energy point, and any talk of nuclear restraint between the biggest powers is worth following. The declaration does not mention India, and India's Ministry of External Affairs had not commented on the meeting as of Thursday evening.

What happens next is far from clear. The declaration is short on details: it does not say how much more fuel will be produced, when the promised nuclear dialogue will begin, or what UN reform would look like in practice. Before the meeting, IANS noted it was uncertain whether the three would even put out a joint statement, so the fact that a declaration came out at all is news in itself. Whether it turns into real action on Ukraine, oil or weapons is the question the coming weeks will answer.

LeadersTrump, Xi, Putin
TalksAbout 90 minutes
OutcomeFour-point declaration

Source ledger · स्रोत खाता

Each fact in this story, where it came from, and how it was checked.

FactSourceCheck
First-ever trilateral meeting of US, China and Russia leaders, Shenzhen, APEC sidelines, ThursdayPTI (published by OrissaPOST)Confirmed, independent outlets
First-ever trilateral meeting of US, China and Russia leaders, Shenzhen, APEC sidelines, ThursdayIANS (published by The Morung Express)Confirmed, independent outlets
Meeting lasted about 90 minutesPTI (published by OrissaPOST)Confirmed, independent outlets
Meeting lasted about 90 minutesTASSConfirmed, independent outlets
Meeting lasted about 90 minutesThe WeekConfirmed, independent outlets
Meeting ended with a four-point 'Declaration Towards Peace'PTI (published by OrissaPOST)Confirmed, independent outlets
Meeting ended with a four-point 'Declaration Towards Peace'TASSConfirmed, independent outlets
Declaration: commitment to UN reform as permanent Security Council membersPTI (published by OrissaPOST)Confirmed, independent outlets
Declaration: commitment to UN reform as permanent Security Council membersTASSConfirmed, independent outlets
Declaration: raise production and supply of refined petroleum products; stable energy flowsPTI (published by OrissaPOST)Confirmed, independent outlets
Declaration: raise production and supply of refined petroleum products; stable energy flowsTASSConfirmed, independent outlets
Declaration: state consent and immunity of officials paramount; ICC and similar bodies must not abuse jurisdictionPTI (published by OrissaPOST)Confirmed, independent outlets
Declaration: state consent and immunity of officials paramount; ICC and similar bodies must not abuse jurisdictionTASSConfirmed, independent outlets
Declaration: nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought; dialogue on nuclear risks and non-proliferationPTI (published by OrissaPOST)Confirmed, independent outlets
Declaration: nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought; dialogue on nuclear risks and non-proliferationTASSConfirmed, independent outlets
Held at Kylin Villa during the 33rd APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting hosted by ChinaIANS (published by The Morung Express)Confirmed, independent outlets
Held at Kylin Villa during the 33rd APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting hosted by ChinaReuters (published by DD News)Confirmed, independent outlets
Trump met Xi and Putin separately before the trilateralIANS (published by The Morung Express)Confirmed, independent outlets
Trump met Xi and Putin separately before the trilateralReuters (published by DD News)Confirmed, independent outlets
Trump said US and China share interest in energy flowing through Strait of HormuzIANS (published by The Morung Express)Confirmed, independent outlets
Trump said US and China share interest in energy flowing through Strait of HormuzReuters (published by DD News)Confirmed, independent outlets
Trump expressed optimism that the US and China could both help on the Russia-Ukraine war (paraphrase of IANS quote)IANS (published by The Morung Express)Confirmed, independent outlets
Trump expressed optimism that the US and China could both help on the Russia-Ukraine war (paraphrase of IANS quote)Reuters (published by DD News)Confirmed, independent outlets
Trump said the three, as biggest nuclear powers, could reduce weapons and lower risk of useIANS (published by The Morung Express)Confirmed, independent outlets
Trump said the three, as biggest nuclear powers, could reduce weapons and lower risk of useThe WeekConfirmed, independent outlets
Trump-Xi talks were their first in two months, after September meeting in WashingtonIANS (published by The Morung Express)Single source
Before the meeting it was unclear whether a joint statement would be issuedIANS (published by The Morung Express)Single source
Declaration does not mention India; no MEA statement on the meeting as of ~19:45 IST ThursdayPTI (published by OrissaPOST)Single source
Declaration does not mention India; no MEA statement on the meeting as of ~19:45 IST ThursdayIANS (published by The Morung Express)Single source

Corrections to this story: none.