Checked, then printedEach story lists its facts, their sources and how they were verified.
NewsKhata
न्यूज़खाता

Every story shows its sources.

← Front page

TechnologyReported

IT Ministry questions home-service apps over in-home footage: report

The ministry has made no public statement on the reported meeting.

A small indoor home camera
Representative image: A home camera. Photo: DeanBarrington / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

The IT Ministry’s secretary chaired a meeting on 12 November with home-service platforms and robotics firms about video recorded inside Indian homes, the Economic Times has reported, citing people aware of the meeting. Other outlets that carried the report named the secretary as S Krishnan and the platforms as Pronto, Urban Company and Snabbit.

The reported concern is whether such footage is used to train robots and whether it reaches AI developers outside India. The ministry has not confirmed the meeting on record.

According to accounts of the report in Entrackr and Inc42, officials asked how the footage is collected, processed and stored, how workers give consent and how people in the household are protected. They also asked whether data is sold or shared with AI developers abroad. The talks covered workers’ rights, consumer privacy and data sovereignty, Entrackr said. “Physical AI” is the industry term for AI that controls robots.

The issue first surfaced in May, when Entrackr reported that Pronto, a Bengaluru startup, was using cameras in customers’ homes and using the clips to train physical AI, Business Standard reported at the time. Pronto said then that the recording was a voluntary pilot. In July it turned the pilot into a paid, opt-in service called Verified, in which workers wear cameras during a visit, MediaNama and Inc42 reported. In October its founder, Anjali Sardana, launched Provision Labs, a physical AI company in San Francisco. Inc42 said the link between Pronto’s household footage and Provision Labs is unclear.

MediaNama reported that Pronto’s account of what happens to the footage has changed. In May the company said footage was deleted within 48 hours and not shared with outside AI labs. In November it said anonymised footage is kept for AI training after a 48-hour window in which the customer can view it, without naming who trains on it or where.

For customers, the main rule today is the Digital Personal Data Protection Act. MediaNama reported that the Act allows personal data to be sent abroad unless the government restricts a particular country, and that no country has been restricted so far. Further conditions in the rules take effect in May 2027, it said. Legal experts cited in the Economic Times report said video and facial images can count as personal data if they can be linked to a worker, according to Entrackr.

Pronto said it shared its current practices, which it says are designed to comply with applicable regulations. It said the data comes from the customer’s booking with the customer’s consent. In May it said on X: “By default there is no camera involved, and when there is, it’s impossible to miss.”

Urban Company said in May that it does not record inside homes. “We are in the business of trust and we take customer trust and privacy extremely seriously,” its chief executive, Abhiraj Singh Bhal, said then. Snabbit’s founder, Aayush Agarwal, wrote on X: “No customer home has ever been recorded by us, in any way.”

Pronto has been asked to submit a detailed account of its data practices, the reports said. The company said it will keep engaging with the ministry.

This report has not been independently confirmed. It is not known whether any footage has gone to developers abroad, or whether the ministry plans new rules. Reports also differ on how many customers were recorded: Business Standard in May cited Pronto as saying the pilot reached 0.1% of customers, while Inc42 this week put it at less than 0.01% of users.

Reported byThe Economic Times
Ministry statementNone so far
StatusNot independently confirmed

Source ledger · स्रोत खाता

Each fact in this story, where it came from, and how it was checked.

FactSourceCheck
Ministry secretary chaired a meeting on 12 Nov with platforms and robotics firmsEconomic Times report, as carried by MediaNamaSingle source
Pronto says it shared practices designed to comply with regulationsMediaNama, EntrackrConfirmed, independent outlets
Urban Company said in May it does not record inside homesMediaNama, Inc42Confirmed, independent outlets
Secretary named as S Krishnan; platforms named as Pronto, Urban Company and SnabbitMediaNama, Entrackr, Inc42 (all citing the Economic Times)Single source
Officials asked about collection, processing and storage of footage, worker consent, household privacy, and sale or sharing with overseas AI developers; talks covered workers’ rights, consumer privacy, data sovereigntyEntrackr, Inc42 (citing the Economic Times)Single source
In May 2026 Entrackr reported Pronto was recording in homes to train physical AI; Pronto called it a voluntary pilotBusiness StandardSingle source
Pronto launched paid opt-in ‘Verified’ service in July, with workers wearing camerasMediaNama, Inc42Confirmed, independent outlets
Founder Anjali Sardana launched Provision Labs (San Francisco) in October; link with Pronto footage unclearMediaNama, Inc42Confirmed, independent outlets
Pronto said in May footage was deleted within 48 hours and not shared with third-party AI labs; in November said anonymised footage is kept for AI training after a 48-hour customer viewing windowMediaNamaSingle source
DPDP Act permits cross-border transfer unless government restricts a country; none restricted yet; further DPDP Rules conditions take effect May 2027MediaNamaSingle source
Legal experts (via ET): video and facial images can be personal data if linkable to a workerEntrackrSingle source
Pronto: data comes from the customer booking journey with customer consent; will keep engaging with the ministryEntrackrSingle source
Pronto X post (May): “By default there is no camera involved, and when there is, it’s impossible to miss.”Business StandardSingle source
Abhiraj Singh Bhal quote: “We are in the business of trust and we take customer trust and privacy extremely seriously.”Business StandardSingle source
Aayush Agarwal (Snabbit) on X: “No customer home has ever been recorded by us, in any way.”Business StandardSingle source
Pronto asked to submit a detailed representation on its data practicesMediaNama, Entrackr (citing the Economic Times)Single source
Pilot reach reported as 0.1% of customers (May) and as less than 0.01% of users (November)Business Standard; Inc42Single source

Corrections to this story: none.